I really wanted to like Zoe’s Tale, but didn’t

Zoe’s Tale is the retelling of the events of “The Last Colony” through the eyes of the daughter of the main protagonists in the earlier novel. What drove me nuts about this book was how perky it was. Well perhaps it was the main character that was perky, but dammit, way *too* perky. Annoyingly perky. And a bit too well adjusted to the point where I thought “look, other than on Disney DVDs, no teenage girl is this perky and well adjusted”. I’ve liked the other books in Scalzi’s “Old Man’s War” series, though I did feel that he didn’t make a convincing argument for the premise of the first book, that old people in new bodies make better soldiers (I don’t think he really sold the “old people in young bodies” thing all that well). That aside, I liked it because the style was reminiscent of The Forever War and Starship Troopers – basically a squad of badasses being badasses and kicking alien butt (sorry Blarkon).  Zoe’s Tale doesn’t go in this direction. It cloyingly retells The Last Colony and the angst that you’d expect from a teenage girl dragged along behind their parents through an interstellar conflict never really eventuates. Where does a character that is extremely well adjusted at the start of the novel get to go emotionally by the end? What lessons can they really learn when they appear to know it all (and don’t just think they do – as I said, the character both way to bubbly and ahead of the curve). 

I think I recall Scalzi saying in some of the notes at the end of The Last Colony that he wouldn’t be revisiting the Old Man’s War universe. By revisiting events that have already transpired, I guess that still stands. I like Scalzi and I’ll read anything he publishes, but, without putting too fine a point on it, this one wasn’t my favourite book he’s written.


8 Responses to “I really wanted to like Zoe’s Tale, but didn’t”

  1. Guru Bob Says:

    Hey Orin – are you aware of this get – together?

  2. Guru Bob Says:

    Oops that should have included this:


  3. havock21 Says:

    now this is one i reckon i could get into. BUT, the others, well I’ll put dem on the maybe list for me. Like I said to JB. I deeded a nap after reading ya reviews, let along the books, FARK, the head hurt.

    OH, and tell that Blarkon bastard he better stay away, IF, he knows whats good for him

  4. 0r1n Says:

    You can tell him over on his blog you know. He talks about you *all the time*

  5. mickH Says:

    I’ve just finished the last colony Orin and was about to buy Zoe’s tale. I still might because like you I like Scalzi.

    I have found in past discussions on the burger that we are of like minds when it comes to books so I read your reviews with interest.

  6. 0r1n Says:

    Mick, it might be worth waiting until the Last Colony has faded a bit from your memory, otherwise you might find it a bit too familiar. I’ve seen some reviewers suggest reading one or the other, but your mileage may vary.

  7. mickH Says:

    Ok makes sense, I’ll get River of Gods first then.

  8. BrianC Says:

    Yeah i didnt like the last colony, i felt as if was being hit by the politics bat all the way through the book, it diverged so rapidly from the story in the rest of the books that i was just left feeling… bored.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: